American Gospel
  • HOME
  • AGTV
    • About AGTV
    • GIFT SUBSCRIPTIONS AND RENTALS
  • CHRIST ALONE (AG1)
    • Testimonial Request
  • CHRIST CRUCIFIED (AG2)
    • Before You Watch
    • Did God Kill Jesus?
  • Spirit & Fire (AG3)
    • AG3 Production Blog
    • AG3 FAQ
  • GROUP VIEWING
  • FAQ
  • CONTACT US
  • NEWSLETTER
  • WORKBOOKS
  • AGTV Bulk Subscriptions
  • HOME
  • AGTV
    • About AGTV
    • GIFT SUBSCRIPTIONS AND RENTALS
  • CHRIST ALONE (AG1)
    • Testimonial Request
  • CHRIST CRUCIFIED (AG2)
    • Before You Watch
    • Did God Kill Jesus?
  • Spirit & Fire (AG3)
    • AG3 Production Blog
    • AG3 FAQ
  • GROUP VIEWING
  • FAQ
  • CONTACT US
  • NEWSLETTER
  • WORKBOOKS
  • AGTV Bulk Subscriptions

RSS Feed

Unequal Weights & Measures?

10/11/2024

1 Comment

 
Picture
A year ago, Dr. Michael Brown dropped out of American Gospel: Spirit & Fire (AG3). Recently some of my critics have been repeating some of Brown's critiques of AG related to the "sin of unequal weights and measures" (claiming I spend too much time critiquing the charismatic camp, and not my own camp). There are a number of problems with this claim:
​
  1. The AG films are based on addressing errors in certain parts of Christianity that I have personally been involved in. I wanted to make these films as a tool to help the people I love (family and friends) understand certain errors in our current churches, or past churches, and find freedom in the Biblical gospel. The people involved in these projects also come from the same place as people who were formerly involved in a Christ-less Christianity, but were graciously saved by God, and are now speaking out and warning the body of Christ about these issues. So to portray the AG films as being made by “outsiders” pointing the finger at a "different camp" (us vs. them) is simply not true. We view our efforts as a self-critique of the Christian church as a whole and as a means to help those we love relearn and rebuild their faith in alignment with Scripture. 
  2. The claim that we only spend time critiquing the charismatic camp is also not true. The first AG film spent the first 40 minutes critiquing moralistic preaching, which is an issue that exists in every "camp" of Christianity. It was literally an error that I experienced in a church that I was attending when I first started considering making the first AG film. The remainder of that 2 hr. 19 min film was focused on the Word of Faith movement, which is a movement within charismatic Christianity (a movement that even charismatics also critique). Our second AG film was 2 hours and 56 minutes and critiqued progressive Christianity. So in the films we've released, we've spent a majority of our time critiquing movements outside of charismatic Christianity.
  3. American Gospel: Spirit & Fire has been a project we've been producing over the past 4 years. During our communication with Dr. Michael Brown, whenever we brought up an error within charismatic Christianity, specifically related to Word of Faith, or NAR, he would deflect that critique and always respond with what he says at the end of our extended trailer (here: https://youtu.be/HWige_01siw?t=702)​
​​"You know the Scripture says that God hates unequal weights and measures, and that's what grieves me as I watch some of this trailer. I know there's an attempt to be balanced, but I could make a whole documentary of all of those that came out of cessationist churches and had their spiritual life totally transformed when they came into the things of the Spirit—the power of the Spirit. Churches that were totally transformed. And I could do a whole documentary about those that left charismatic, Pentecostal churches—left some of these spiritual movements and went into a cessationist church, or a Reformed Church and their faith became bankrupt and they fell away from the Lord…" —Dr. Michael Brown
According to Michael Brown, the only way I could have made a "balanced" trailer and docuseries in the sight of God was if I made a film that also critiqued the dangers of both cessationism and Reformed theology in addition to the New Apostolic Reformation (NAR). I think this is coming from a mistaken view that we are offering cessationism and Reformed theology as the main solutions to the problems in NAR or the Word of Faith movement. If you've watched the previous AG films, this is clearly not the case; while issues related to cessationism and Reformed theology were discussed, the main emphasis has always been clarity on the person and work of Christ (the gospel). I also never promised to make a film critiquing those other topics, and Michael Brown knew this. My goal of a balanced film was to critique ONE movement and allow those we are critiquing to respond to those critiques (not allow them to shift the discussion to unrelated topics).

Are there dangers, errors, or sin happening in Reformed or cessationist churches? Of course! Could I address any of these errors in future films? Yes, but I am not making a film on these topics right now. It's absurd that I would be expected to conform my project to how Michael Brown views opposing "camps" of Christianity, in order to avoid being accused of committing the sin of unequal weights and measures.

In the end, I realized that Michael Brown's standard of "unequal weights and measures" was his attempt to distract attention away from the topic of NAR (red herring fallacy) and an attempt to discredit me by accusing me of hypocrisy for not seeing or addressing the sins within my own "camp" (a Tu Quoque fallacy, a.k.a. "you too" or "whataboutism").
​

Finally, do the doctrines of cessationism or Reformed theology specifically cause a lack of spiritual life, leading to a bankrupt faith as Michael Brown claims? No. The absence of the GOSPEL (Christ) being preached within ANY type of church creates these dangers. When we critique moralistic preaching, a confusion of law and gospel, the Word of Faith movement, progressive Christianity, or the New Apostolic Reformation, we are focusing our critique on errors related to adding to or subtracting from the gospel, which are errors that any "camp" of Christianity can fall into. The gospel and its clarity will always be my primary concern, which is why I believe that viewing people through the lens of opposing "camps" in terms of secondary issues is unhealthy. My goal in this project has always been to bring both cessationists and continuationists together to critique errors in NAR that distort the gospel.
1 Comment

    Brandon Kimber

    Brandon is the director of American Gospel series, and  President of the streaming service AGTV.

    Archives

    December 2024
    October 2024
    August 2024
    July 2024
    June 2024
    May 2024
    March 2024
    February 2024
    January 2024
    November 2023
    October 2023
    July 2023
    May 2023
    March 2023
    January 2023
    December 2022

    Categories

    All

    RSS Feed

IMDB

Transition Studios Home Page

Copyright © 2021 American Gospel Motion Picture, LLC, AG2 Motion Picture, LLC, All Rights Reserved